Back to the Basics: Knowledge, Sharing, and Hiding

Standard

This week I decided to start a little more general with my readings, trying to bring myself back to what we’re all talking about: knowledge management. With that in mind, I picked up Tsouskas to read about organizational knowledge. And I am glad I did. 

Sometimes I get so bogged down in trying to understand all theories and make them fit with each other I forget they may conflict or use words differently. Tsouskas was a great reminder that, hey, sometimes when an author says knowledge what they mean and what I think in my head are not the same thing. I’ve had to do some double (or triple) readings in the past just to make sense of a word used in an unexpected way.

Tsouskas draws upon the (mostly-but-not-always-agreed-upon) distinction between data, information, and knowledge to give readers a definition of personal knowledge and then build a definition of organizational knowledge. I absolutely love that he uses a call center as his case-study; call centers are the link between an organization and customers, and if the information the call center is relaying is wrong then customers might not return. A poorly informed call center can be crippling (depending on the business). Just imagine: what if you had to call your internet service provider because your wifi just got cut and the representative you speak with has never heard of a modem, a router, MPS, or an Ethernet cable? If that were me, I’d be pretty mad. I’d probably be tempted to switch providers, or at least look around for other options.

Back to organizational knowledge, however, Tsouskas mentions the need for generalizations and rules. These are based on what the organizational community has experienced in the past (all that knowledge sharing, story telling, and knowledge transfer RHMaxsonakellerkamrynwies, and I have talked about before). Amin and Roberts disagree, to an extent. No, this will not make my head explode with two conflicting theories. Not yet, anyways.

Amin and Roberts bring up a good point that too much generalization is unhelpful. They emphasize that details on the situation matter. Granted, Tsouskas is talking about organizational knowledge in general and Amin and Roberts are talking about knowing in communities of practice. The parallels are not exact. Yet the concepts speak to me for the same context of that call center: the call center must have generalizations and rules (so information is given quickly), but those generalizations can’t be so general that the information is not useful (i.e.: an instruction to “use X to find Y”). They also can’t be so detailed that the information is difficult to sort through quickly to find the answer which is relevant to the call. There has to be a middle ground, a happy medium, a balance between generalization and specification.

While on the subject of organizational knowledge and the level of detail it contains, I also read Connelly, Zweig, Webster, and Trougakos‘ article on knowledge hiding. I couldn’t help it; when thinking about generalizing, I had to wonder if that meant knowledge was being hidden from employees.

Connelly, Zweig, Webster, and Trougakos‘ study on knowledge hiding gives proof that it exists, and in some ways I think it is a good thing. I can understand “hiding” knowledge which is not relevant to your job. For example, it’s not necessary for you to know how to build a computer in order to use one (and taking the time to teach all that detail may be considered a “non-value added task” since you aren’t being asked to build computers). But knowledge hiding should not occur for any task-related activities. You should always be given all the information you need to do your job correctly. One thing they did not cover, however, was unintentional knowledge hiding. They state at the very beginning that they define knowledge hiding as an intentional act, but that still leaves me wondering about the unintentional acts: the assumptions, the unopened emails, the missed calls, and honest forgetting.

Words: 665

Resources:

Amin, A., & Roberts, J. (2008). Knowing in action: Beyond communities of practice. Research Policy, 37(2), 353–369. doi:10.1016/j.respol.2007.11.003

Connelly, C. E., Zweig, D., Webster, J., & Trougakos, J. P. (2012). Knowledge hiding in organizations. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 33(1), 64–88. doi:10.1002/job.737

Tsoukas, H. (2001). What is organizational knowledge. Journal of Management Studies, 38(7), 973993. doi:10.1111/14676486.00268

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “Back to the Basics: Knowledge, Sharing, and Hiding

  1. I really liked that you wanted to get back to “knowledge management”. I know I get so caught in the details of each article that I forget sometimes what we are actually learning about. Sometimes finding the good middle ground between too many details and too much generalization is a tough thing to find. I guess it is something that is found through trial and error? To skip to the end of your article, I also wondered about the unintentional acts and what impact they play on organizations.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. It can get so complicated that we get hyper-focused on the details, which seems to be a real part of our existence. We get so bogged down in trying to process so much information that sometime, we stop seeing the big picture.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. ” They also can’t be so detailed that the information is difficult to sort through quickly to find the answer which is relevant to the call. There has to be a middle ground, a happy medium, a balance between generalization and specification.”

    This is a nice observation and it raises what for me is a super interesting question: what’s the minimal amount of explication needed given what we can justifiably expect someone’s level of tacit knowledge to be?

    Like

  4. I also had fun differentiating and then trying to conceptualize what knowledge actually means from one author to another. Reading this many articles can easily melt your thought process so it was nice to read something that broke things down in a helpful way.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s